Most helpful, recommending the game
From starting the game to end credits a recurring thought continued pulsing in the recesses of my brain through every session of play whenever I booted up Returnal. A feeling of familiarity, and one I attribute to an earlier playthrough of indie game called Signalis. Sure both games aren’t quite the same considering Returnal is a roguelike while the other one isn’t. And yet both share similar qualities I find fascinating to recall while playing Returnal. -both have female protagonists who must brave the unknown -both are badass and not overpowered characters granted blessed powers or mary sues. Reminds me a lot of Samus(Metroid), Ellen Ripley(Alien), Leeloo(5th Element). Kudos to developers(Housemarque) for making another female protagonist I like. -both are set in sci-fi worlds with elements of horror, psychological, survival -both suffer, persevere, overcome incredible hurdles(bosses)external or internally -both share similar themes/messaging/execution The last point is pretty important and quite honestly makes or breaks the game for me. Considering 90% I was fully onboard with nearly everything offered. I’m still shaking my head at the level of mixed feelings that smack dab me straight on the middle yet leaning positive still. So! In an effort to dissect my mixed feelings I’ll first display what Returnal didn’t work out for me. Then move onto what it does well. I think both have a tendency to go too cryptic for my tastes. This isn’t a major knock off of both titles, rather the execution/delivery of both leads the player to at least in my eyes without any clear definitive answers. I’m fine with elements not giving me a clear cut answer, if the execution lines up and I can draw sufficient evidence to deduce, analyze a sensible rational conclusion. The fact I had to watch several videos and read some thorough posts online to discern what the F happen and understand the whole narrative leads me to conclude I am a truly living up to my username and two anytime a game doesn’t appropriately catch the player by the time end credits roll like a fish biting a hook on fishing pole leads me to conclude there is something wrong with me or the game doesn’t have enough balls to straight up give a neatly tied ribbon to tie everything up(tbf fine for games not to have all the answers if done well). I’m left in the end, with an overall emptiness, not hollow or a satisfying feeling upon credits rolling but a mixed experience. Signalis, Silent Hill 1, Omori, Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice, Metro 2033 , offered various different psychological approaches, I found myself liking so I have a strong feeling the roguelike aspect is what’s giving me trouble. Speaking of that aspect, the metaprogression could be better because, while you can keep certain abilities similar to a metroidvania, we are ultimately at the mercy of the same health, back to the same default weapon, and any passives we have aren’t saved. So players have to survive enough in a run, get good RNGSUS rolls of proper weapon(wpn) variety and wpn proficiency(essentially better stats on a wep), passives like extra health, and useful items to survive. Takes more time to acquire said vital resources to survive and beat any enemies/bosses before moving onto the next zone. And we don't have a gazillion items to choose from compared to RoR. I had dozens of retries in a single biome because I just couldn’t find any good viable RNGSUS rolls and even when attaining the goods a crash to desktop may or may not happen, which kills my momentum and incentive to keep going. Doesn’t help with the fact- I had to endure constant crashes to desktop everytime I played a session. Ok no big deal, that shouldn’t be a problem when any roguelike worth their salt usually saves the progress before a crash to desktop(CTD) and you’re right. Returnal does have this saving grace, but here’s the kicker. My crashes for some godawful reason continued even after spending hours trying to find a solution on the web without a clear solution. Imagine playing sessions of 10min, 20min, 30min, 40min, 1 hour, 2 hours, or any variable within that timeframe and bam! CTD. No big deal, I'll just play again, 10min later CTD again. Ok no big deal I'll just play and restart. CTD after 15 min. Another 40min session until CTD. You know how infuriating that becomes when I’m trying desperately to focus on a ROGUELIKE game where a mistake can be deadly and my character has to restart again like the greek fella Sisyphus repeatedly trying to push the boulder up a mountain, only to see it roll down just as I was so close to the top. But I digress for all my bemoaning. I must praise what Returnal does pretty well Worldbuilding lore, story narrative clues, are a nice periodic dosage to keep the player vested in the roguelike loop. Dripfeeding narrative breadcrumbs in pretty cool and unlocking said pieces from dying over again or by continued progression in the overall campaign leaves me wanting to uncover the whole jigsaw metaphorically speaking. Out of all the Roguelikes i’ve played, Risk of Rain(1+2), Into the Breach, Dead Cells, Dungeon of the Endless and FTL, Returnal easily hits the highest amount of interest I've had thus far in terms of lorebuilding. Which I admit is small, but a noticeable upgrade into AAA roguelike quality I expect. Exploring Planet Atropos is sick. The science fiction alien flora/structures during biome levels we can venture/traverse/find secrets are AAA levels of gorgeous. Didn’t see any copy paste reused texture palettes or same terrain geography with the procedural generated levels, granted I feel the devs tweaked the values so the areas are somewhat familiar yet still maintain unfamiliarity as you re-enter the biome after a run. Levels are varied without being too strictly linear for my tastes with multiple pathways, verticality(god i love this in particular). The main meat of combat is pretty satisfying for a third person shooter. Run and gun gameplay feels good, not awkward or janky, animations from entering frenetic combat to transitioning into dodges while smoothly slowly changing my camera didn’t disorient me. Bonus points for making the dodge button pretty slick too. A decent selection of guns you’ll find, range from classics like pistol, shotgun, rifles, and my personal favorite is a rifle which can go full automatic. If you think that’s boring remember this is sci-fi so all guns have different tweaks and innate properties and alieny visual presence to match the aesthetic. By far the biggest strength are the boss fights. Each biome has an end level boss before you can have the permission to cross to another biome. And each boss is formidable. Usually having multiple stages to them, different patterns between and the music is ambient as heck, leaving me nodding my head to the beat while I'm fighting and vibing. I swear if someone called this a rhythm groovy game i would not correct them heh. Despite my mixed feelings severely affecting my overall experience particularly the ending and the crashes galore. I still hesitantly recommend Returnal considering I think the whole game deserves a playthrough to see where your feelings fall whether in the good, bad or mixed. Nevertheless, I don’t think my negatives truly outweigh the positives. I firmly believe a fair amount in the gun and run combat, epic boss fights, world biome level eye candy, and drip feeding intriguing lore packets/audio logs is enough to invest any newcomers to the genre and allow for potentially a fun roguelike playthroughs in spite of some red flags I stated earlier. If nothing else, it’s also given me more interest in playing cryptic psychological titles and learning from them to further my understanding. 6.2/10
