Most helpful, recommending the game
Steam really needs to add neutral options for games already, because that is the option I'd choose for this at present. I think Transport Fever 3 is extremely good for what it adds and does now, but there are things that are wrong with it at release here that others have mentioned. I will add to and change this as time goes on. Get ready, this is a long review. The big thing I want to say 1st is the fact that Transport Fever 2 also had the *same exact kind of initial release* as TpF3 here. Ya'll just forget because its been 8 freaking years now and you guys have the memory of a wet sponge. Transport Fever 2 was not as people describe it, "better", overnight and it took Urban Games around a year or 2 to get it to where it more or less has stayed for the past 5 years. In fact a lot of features weren't in the base game of TpF2 that it eventually got over time, and I think this will be the same. This is just the initial release after all and TpF2 was just as unpolished at release as this is. Most just don't remember and are looking at 2 with rose colored glasses. For those not wanting to buy it now, well frankly if you're debating, just don't. Wait till later then. No one is forcing you to buy the game now and you can continue playing Transport Fever 2 for now. Now onto the actual subject of what's currently needing to be changed here: 1. Yes the oil rig: I get it, it doesn't fit the era. They need to move this to only spawn after 1960. 2. Loaded trains not weighing more: This one is entirely valid and people saying "the physics aren't there anymore" literally do not know how to word crap. Currently the trains only take the number of cars/wagons behind them into account. Not really the end all for me personally, but definitely something that should be fixed in the future. 3. Towns growing way too fast: This is another entirely valid thing. They do grow way too fast. I myself am dying at the fact that "Fast" is like 200 more population every 5 minutes. Its a bit ridiculous and completely overwhelms the player. 4. Vehicle selection: Yes, there's a lot less base game vehicles and this genuinely is something that I was expecting to have more of. They eliminated a lot of things, including a lot of American locomotives and rolling stock. My hope with this is more is added back as time goes on, but what they did here for what people do not understand or get is the rework of the game for the 1900 start date. You start with very little and work your way up, this is why early game for like 20 years, there's not much available...the entire game start now just has been shifted forward 50 years. Don't forget the entirety of the 1800s in TpF2 only gives you like 5 or 6 locomotives each for the USA, Russia and Europe (there's no Asian ones). For America you only started with the freaking Baldwin 6 wheels in 1850 in TpF2 and you have that for like 20 years *as well* before you get the 4-4-0 American. So what's genuinely hilarious to me is you guys completely forgot this is how the game has always been structured with base game vehicles, its just now been shifted to 1900 as the start. 5. Vehicle capacities for passengers, maybe some cargo, are horribly imbalanced for the new game: Yes...seriously. Its so bad because the population density and whatnot has been increased so much that it doesn't even remotely reflect the new game. We still have the TpF2 capacities when we need new ones for TpF3 to suit the new town growth and map population. 6. Paved Road availability: 1940 is way too late for this as we should get some form of paved roads in the 1920s. It doesn't have to be full on highways, but at the least they could give us paved streets and 2 to 4 lane highways like we had in TpF2 as well frankly, I see what they did here. They are making it so you get highways around when the real life ones we still have today, at least here in the USA, started being constructed which yes, was around the 1940s if you do your history research. While in concept it might have been an OK idea, in practice its terrible for gameplay. I'll throw traffic lights in here as well, they need to come earlier too. 7. The GUI can be redone again since there's a lot of demand for it. Personally I don't mind it all that much, but whatever they do I can adapt to very quickly. I guess I'm just built different, lol. 8. How cargo is handled: Yeah...this needs to be improved as you can't set unloading now and vehicles just do this automatically without your direct control. The predictive load system when setting up a line is also a bit annoying and could be an option or eliminated. Cargo before having set destinations made it extremely easy to route everything as it would just more or less automatically do it for you after you set up the line and added vehicles. Now you have to manually route it yourself but they've not actually given us the tools at this stage to do that in an easy manner. You not being able to set any unload amounts for stops prevents you from being able to distribute cargo the way you want it easily. Edit: I figured out a way around this for now and its using the "Max Stop Time" timer and setting it to like a few seconds. The vehicle will just drive on then without having fully unloaded. Maybe this is the way they intended you to use the new system, I don't know. But its not intuitive to the end user at all in reality. Obviously this isn't a completely comprehensive list of everything wrong right now because to list everything would make this so stupidly long it would be ridiculous. Summary: Realistically what happened here to me is that the Youtubers and other content creators provided no actual input to this game and were just a bunch of "Yes Men" to Urban Games. These kinds of people are the exact opposite of what you want to have test or provide feedback on a game. They do 1 of 2 things: Say absolutely nothing or recommend nothing, or go and say "its great!" with no constructive criticism whatsoever. Paradox from what I've heard was also part of the play testing and I think that goes without saying they just looked at the game, gave the thumbs up, and then that was it. At this stage I will give Urban Games the benefit of the doubt in that they've had this trend since the beginning in fact with Train Fever. They have oversight which is the thing that really shoots themselves in the foot with every initial release they do and them having to quickly scramble to undo the damage done by the initial release. I think that now the actual player base has their hands on the game, they can give some real constructive feedback to Urban Games and subsequently fix all the various problems with it.
